“Amazing grace, how sweet the sound, that saved a wretch like me.”
We’ve sung those words countless times. They are among the most familiar lyrics in all of Christendom. Hymns may come and go, but Amazing Grace has endured across centuries, cultures, and denominations.
But do we really understand what we’re singing?
And if we truly understood the story behind it—the life of John Newton, the man who penned those lyrics—would we welcome him into our churches today?
It’s worth considering.
The Story Behind the Song
John Newton was born in 1725 in England, the son of a sea captain. Though raised with some knowledge of Christianity by his mother, she died when he was just seven years old. Left mostly to his own devices and the influence of the seafaring world, Newton quickly descended into rebellion, profanity, and outright rejection of God.
By his own admission, Newton was not merely indifferent to Christianity—he was a blasphemer, a mocker of faith, and a man enslaved to sin.
In time, Newton became deeply involved in the transatlantic slave trade. He worked on slave ships, eventually becoming a captain. His job? Capturing and transporting human beings, shackled and suffering, across oceans. He treated people as cargo. He profited from pain. And he did it without remorse.
Until grace found him.
During a particularly violent storm at sea, Newton’s ship was on the verge of capsizing. In desperation, he cried out to God—perhaps for the first time in sincerity. That storm became the beginning of his transformation.
It was not instant. His repentance unfolded slowly. Even after that storm, Newton continued working in the slave trade for a few more years. But over time, the Spirit of God began to shape his conscience. Eventually, he left the trade entirely, became an Anglican minister, and spent the rest of his life preaching the Gospel and campaigning for the abolition of slavery.
He mentored William Wilberforce, who would later lead the charge to end slavery in Britain.
And in 1772, John Newton wrote the words to a hymn that captured the wonder of being rescued by God:
“I once was lost, but now am found; was blind, but now I see.”
What If He Walked Through Our Doors?
Now imagine this: what if John Newton—former slave trader, blasphemer, profane sailor—walked into our church today?
Would we embrace him?
Would we trust him?
Would we allow him to teach Sunday School? Lead a small group? Preach? Or would we keep him at arm’s length, always suspicious of his past?
Grace is beautiful when it’s abstract. But grace gets uncomfortable when it’s personal. When it means welcoming the former addict, the felon, the unfaithful, the abortionist, or the oppressor. It gets especially uncomfortable when that person caused real harm to others.
It’s one thing to sing “saved a wretch like me.” It’s another thing to mean it—and believe it for others.
The Gospel Is Scandalous
John Newton understood the scandal of grace. He knew exactly how vile he had been, and it only magnified his awe of God’s mercy. He didn’t minimize his past; he brought it into the light as proof of God’s redemptive power.
Late in life, nearly blind and nearing death, Newton reportedly said:
“My memory is nearly gone, but I remember two things: that I am a great sinner, and that Christ is a great Savior.”
This is the Gospel. Not that God saves people who deserve it, but that He rescues the undeserving, the broken, the wrecked.
That includes you. And it includes the John Newtons of the world.
Do We Have That Kind of Grace?
So here’s the hard question: Do we extend that kind of grace to others?
Would your church be a place where someone like John Newton could be restored?
- Would the congregation whisper about his past, or testify about God’s power?
- Would he be disqualified by his past, or welcomed as a trophy of grace?
- Would he be seen only as what he once was, or as what Christ has made him to be?
We need to ask ourselves: Do we believe the Gospel is strong enough to redeem the worst of sinners? Because if not, then it isn’t strong enough to save any of us.
The Church Must Lead With Grace
Jesus didn’t come for the righteous, but for sinners (Luke 5:32). He didn’t avoid the messy stories—He stepped into them. He dined with tax collectors, touched lepers, forgave adulterers, and delivered demoniacs.
And He still does.
If our churches are going to reflect the heart of Christ, they must be safe places for the lost to be found, for the blind to see, for the “wretches” to be made whole.
That means:
- Listening to stories without judgment
- Giving space for people to repent and grow
- Affirming the new identity of those in Christ
- Offering forgiveness that mirrors the cross
It also means learning to see people as God sees them—not as the sum of their sins, but as His beloved children, made new by grace.
Be Encouraged, Not Condemned
Maybe your story isn’t as dramatic as Newton’s. Or maybe it’s darker than anyone knows. Either way, Amazing Grace applies to you.
Don’t let shame keep you from coming to God. And don’t let pride keep you from welcoming others.
Whether you’re the prodigal son who wandered far, or the older brother who stayed home but never understood grace, the Father is calling you to the feast.
Final Thought: Sing It Like You Mean It
The next time you sing Amazing Grace, think about the man who wrote it. Think about the lives he harmed—and the Savior who redeemed him.
And ask yourself:
- Who in my life needs that kind of grace?
- Have I received it deeply enough to give it freely?
- Can I believe that God really does make all things new?
The church is not a museum of saints. It’s a hospital for sinners.
May we become a people who not only sing about grace—but live it, offer it, and embody it.
Reflective Questions:
- Who would you struggle to welcome into your church?
- Are there people you’ve labeled by their past instead of their redemption?
- How has God shown you amazing grace?
Scripture References:
- Luke 5:31–32 – “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick.”
- 1 Timothy 1:15–16 – “Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners—of whom I am the worst.”
- Ephesians 2:4–5 – “But because of his great love for us, God, who is rich in mercy, made us alive…”
sethmglazier.com 
Leave a comment