“If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained your brother.” —Matthew 18:15
The church is supposed to be the place where love abounds, grace is extended, and Christ is exalted. But if you’ve spent any time in church, you know this: it’s full of people—and people are complicated. Some build you up. Others let you down. And sometimes, sin gets in the way.
So what do you do when you have a problem with someone in your church? When you’ve been hurt, disappointed, or angered—what’s the right way forward?
The answer is not avoidance. It’s not gossip. And it’s not explosive confrontation either.
Jesus gave us a better way. Scripture outlines both the heart and the steps to take when sin shows up in the house of God.
The Church Is a Family—Not a Fantasy
When you walk into church, you walk into a family of sinners saved by grace. You’re not entering heaven—you’re entering a hospital.
The people sitting beside you are people in process. So are the ones preaching and leading. The church isn’t perfect, but it belongs to the One who is. And because we belong to Him, we must learn to handle conflict, sin, and disappointment His way—not the world’s way.
1. Start With Your Own Heart
“First take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye.” —Matthew 7:5
Before addressing someone else’s fault, examine your own motives.
- Are you acting out of wounded pride or righteous concern?
- Is your goal restoration or revenge?
- Have you prayed about it—or just talked about it?
Repentance always begins in the mirror. Conflict handled in pride will cause deeper division. But conflict handled in humility can become an opportunity for grace.
2. Go to Them—Not to Others
“If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone.” —Matthew 18:15
Jesus didn’t leave this open to interpretation. When someone offends you, you don’t post it, tweet it, or spread it in the prayer circle. You go directly to the person.
This honors God, preserves unity, and gives the other person a chance to repent without being humiliated.
Private sin deserves a private confrontation. Public sin may require a more public response (more on that later). But the principle stands: talk to people, not about them.
3. Seek Reconciliation, Not Victory
“If he listens to you, you have gained your brother.” —Matthew 18:15b
The goal is not to win an argument—it’s to win a brother or sister back into unity and righteousness.
Sometimes that means you will need to forgive, even when you’re right.
Other times, it means you’ll need to apologize, even when you only see part of the problem.
If someone listens, humbles themselves, and responds with repentance, rejoice. Don’t rub it in. Don’t hold it over them. Don’t keep score. Grace is meant to heal, not haunt.
4. Involve Others Only When Necessary
“But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you…” —Matthew 18:16
If private confrontation fails, Jesus gives permission for a witness-based escalation. This isn’t about ganging up—it’s about accountability.
Why? Because sin can be blinding. And truth spoken by multiple voices can bring clarity, conviction, or confirmation.
Church leaders may need to be involved if the issue affects others or if there’s a pattern of unrepentant sin.
5. When Sin Is Public and Ongoing
Paul gives strong instructions in 1 Corinthians 5 for dealing with blatant, unrepentant sin in the church. He tells the church not to celebrate false tolerance but to remove the offender—not to shame them, but to wake them up to the seriousness of their sin.
This kind of church discipline is rare today, but it is biblical when done with tears, truth, and a desire for redemption.
“Godly sorrow brings repentance that leads to salvation and leaves no regret.” —2 Corinthians 7:10
The end goal is never to condemn—it is to restore.
6. When Leaders Fail
There’s a higher standard for those in leadership.
“Do not entertain an accusation against an elder unless it is brought by two or three witnesses. But those elders who are sinning you are to reprove before everyone, so that the others may take warning.” —1 Timothy 5:19–20
Church leaders are not above correction. They are under greater scrutiny and accountability. But accusations must be handled carefully—never based on rumors, always with evidence, and always in the fear of God.
If you have a serious concern about a leader’s conduct, don’t bury it. Follow the biblical process. God values integrity and holiness in His church.
7. Sometimes You Leave—and Sometimes You Stay
If the issue involves serious abuse, doctrinal compromise, or unchecked sin, God may lead you to leave a church. But not every offense is a reason to walk away.
Sometimes He calls you to stay and contend for unity. Sometimes your obedience is to forgive. Sometimes it’s to lead by example. Be sure your leaving isn’t just an escape from discomfort—but a response to His Spirit.
Final Thoughts: The Church Is Worth Fighting For
The church is God’s idea, not man’s invention. She is messy, but she is still His bride. He gave His life for her. He’s coming back for her. And He calls us to walk in love, even when it’s hard.
If you have a problem with someone in your church, don’t bury it. Don’t broadcast it. Don’t weaponize it.
Bring it to God. Then bring it to them. Then bring it to healing.
Because conflict, handled in Christ, becomes a canvas for grace.
And when the church lives this way, the world sees not just our unity—but the power of the Gospel that holds us together.
sethmglazier.com 
Leave a comment